To Mulch or Not to Mulch…That Is the Question

Whether to mulch or not to mulch a garden area is sometimes a decision gardeners need to make. At first, it may seem best to mulch every part of a garden that is bare of flowers or plants. After all, gardeners know that mulching the garden can be quite beneficial.

Mulching helps insulate garden soil from temperature extremes. It also helps retain and preserve moisture around plants, suppress weeds, and prevent soil erosion.

Using an organic material as mulch can have an additional benefit. Organic matter breaks down easily or decomposes. This decayed matter can be full of nutrients for the soil. Plants naturally use up valuable soil nutrients during the growing season. Organic mulches and composting can help enrich the soil by replacing some of those nutrients.

Also consider the location of the garden site. If the area naturally stays moist, there may be little need to mulch. It may be more beneficial to leave the ground exposed to sunlight. Most plants need dry periods between moist spells to fully complete their growing cycles.

It's true that most plants benefit greatly from mulch. New bulbs, like tulips, do well after planting when covered with a layer of mulch. It helps keep the soil from going through extreme freeze-thaw conditions during cold winter months, preventing bulbs from being severely pushed up and down or heaved from the ground.

Another group of plants, ornamental grasses, may benefit from mulch. It helps maintain moisture levels and soil temperature and can prevent roots from being exposed to excessive cold or heat.

Sometimes, though, it may be better to leave the soil around plants completely bare. Iris is a good example. Iris is a plant that likes sunlight, with rhizomes almost completely uncovered. The archive says Iris depends on sunlight baking the rhizomes for a good portion of the day to produce blooms each season.

Then there are plants that may or may not benefit from mulching. Hosta is one of those plants. For some hosta, mulch can be troublesome because it can provide moist, dark places for slugs and snails. On the other hand, a layer of mulch could be harmless or helpful over winter to keep roots from being heaved and exposed during freeze-thaw periods.

So the decision about whether to mulch a garden area may not be cut and dry. It can depend on the location and the particular plant.

Before you mulch a bed, clear the weeds already growing there. Our weeding tools guide explains which tool works best for each type of weed.

Filed under: Soil, Compost & Mulch